Stretching vs. Resistance Training: Which One’s Best for Your Calves?
- Julian Simpson
- 3 days ago
- 3 min read
Stretching vs. Resistance Training: Which One’s Best for Your Calves?
If you’ve ever wondered whether holding a stretch or lifting your own body weight is better for your legs, you’re not alone. A recent study gave us some pretty interesting insights into how static stretching (SS) and resistance training (RT) affect your calf muscles — particularly the plantar flexors, which are the muscles that help you push off the ground when walking, running, or jumping.
The Study in a Nutshell
Researchers took 36 healthy young men and split them into three groups:
Static Stretching (SS) – Standing calf stretches 3 times per week for 6 weeks.
Resistance Training (RT) – Bodyweight calf raises with a slow eccentric (lowering) phase, 3 times per week for 6 weeks.
Control – Did nothing.
Before and after the 6-week program, the scientists measured:
Range of motion (ROM) – How far you can flex your ankle.
Muscle strength – Through different types of contractions (pushing, pulling, and holding).
Muscle thickness – Using ultrasound to see if the calves got bigger.
Passive stiffness & stretch tolerance – Basically, how “tight” your muscles feel and how much they can tolerate being stretched.
What They Found
Both stretching and resistance training helped participants increase their ankle ROM, which is great for flexibility and injury prevention. But here’s the twist:
Static stretching decreased muscle stiffness. Your calves became more “pliable,” which is exactly what you want if tight calves are holding you back.
Resistance training didn’t change stiffness much, but it increased muscle strength and size — think more powerful calf raises and better push-off power.
Both methods improved ROM, but the underlying reason was probably increased stretch tolerance, not just a change in muscle stiffness.
In simpler terms: Stretching makes your muscles feel looser; resistance training makes your muscles stronger and a bit longer.
What Does This Mean for You?
If your goal is flexibility and looser calves, static stretching is your friend. If your goal is stronger, more powerful calves, resistance training is the way to go. And honestly? Combining both is probably the best recipe for happy, healthy legs.
Here’s a simple takeaway:
Goal | Best Approach |
Looser, more flexible calves | Static stretching |
Stronger calves | Resistance training (calf raises) |
Both strength & flexibility | Combine SS + RT |
Quick Tips from Your Chiropractor
For stretching, hold a calf stretch for about 30 seconds, 3 times per leg, 3 times per week.
There isnt any bonus points for over stretching , after about 90 seconds there isnt much medical benefit .
For resistance training, try 3 sets of 10 slow calf raises, focusing on a controlled lowering phase to maximise strength gains.
Always listen to your body — a gentle stretch should feel good, not painful.
The Bottom Line
You don’t have to pick sides. Stretching and strengthening both have benefits for your calves, and both can improve your ankle mobility. Whether you’re an athlete, a weekend warrior, or just trying to keep your feet happy, incorporating a mix of stretches and strength exercises into your routine will keep your lower legs strong, flexible, and less prone to injury.
For more information about how we can help YOU with your pain and improve your underlying dysfunction so the problem doesn’t come back .
Please call Health Wise Chiropractic 03 9467 7889 or book online to see one of our Chiropractors in Sunbury or Melton/Strathtulloh Today!
We are also really proud to offer our patients an APP for their Mobile- iPad. With access to your rehab exercises and our health tip blogs with over 600 articles.
Chiropractic has moved online. We offer our online program -STAND CORRECTED- To help you through the day.
We have over 30 programs on different health conditions
Each program contains
- Information about the conditions
- things to do and things to avoid
- nutrition advice
- all the stretches that are needed to help
Murakami Y, Konrad A, Kasahara K, Yoshida R, Warneke K, Behm DG, Nakamura M. Comparison between 6 weeks of static stretching and resistance training programs on passive and active properties of plantar flexors. a randomized controlled trial. Front Physiol. 2025 Oct 15;16:1555253. doi: 10.3389/fphys.2025.1555253. PMID: 41169885; PMCID: PMC12569644.
The distinction often comes down to whether you’re targeting capacity or flexibility, and those don’t always progress in parallel. It’s a bit like dynamics around https://www.roaringmegs.co.nz/ The Pokies where short-term adjustments can feel effective, yet without building underlying resilience the longer-term outcome doesn’t necessarily improve.